Posts Tagged ‘reading’

Book Review – The Giver

Tuesday, October 6th, 2009

My 7th grade daughter had to read The Giver for her Language Arts class.    Now back when I was in the 7th grade we had English class, not Language Arts, but I actually prefer the latter. Or maybe English Arts. But that’s irrelevant to what I was going tosay!  Sorry… I’m soooo easily distracted…

The Giver is set in a futuristic utopia in which citizens trade autonomy for peace.The setting unfolds as  the good guy, a coming-of-age boy named Jonas, faces the assignment of his lifelong career at the ripe old age of twelve!  Written in a narrative style from his point of view, he explores the limitations and advantages of his societal structure, anticipating along with his peers, the coming life changes.  He worries about his future.  His friendships. His family.

It’s not far into the book that you can figure out that when misfits of society are “released” that they are in fact put down like a rabid or sick dog, basically, as opposed to “lost” which comes from some accidental death or illness.  That’s no surprise.

Nor is it a surprise that Jonas is chosen for a pivotal influential role in this cute little world, nor the fact that his struggling with this role is going to lead to some pretty dramatic changes for everyone!

But the ending loses it.  It’s weak, poorly developed, and lacks any sort of dynamic twist.  (Spoiler…)

(more…)

Think you know yourself?

Sunday, July 12th, 2009

I’m reading Pilgrim by Timothy Findley currently.  So far, I’m not that impressed. I’d sure like to know more about Carl  Jung though, and he occasionally makes an appearance in this novel.  Of course, being a novel, all to get is Findley’s own view of Jung.  I akin the book to old dark wool suit on a rainy day.  That’s how it feels.  But here’s an excerpt:

Everyone is a liar – one way or another – to one degree or another.  No one can tell the truth about themselves.  It is quite impossible.

Something must always be justified.  Always, something must be justified.  we do each other dreadful harm because we refuse to justify the foibles of others – only our own.

One place to see this fact is while driving.  Have you ever “D&*& you you M*(&^(& F^(*&^ you idiot don’t you know to LOOK before you do a lane change?”   I’m sure you haven’t ever. No never! Ever ever.  Performed a lane change not knowing there was a car in your own blind spot!

But here’s the rub:  Traffic is one thing.  But extend this principle into our broader lives, and you can see how our own limited scope, failure to see beyond ourselves, can hurt ourselves, in a mutual sense.